Saturday, October 15, 2016

Magazine and Pattern Review: My Image Elsa Sweater

The folks at Made by Oranges, based in the Netherlands, recently reached out to me to see if I wanted to try some of their sewing magazines, My Image and B-Trendy

Each My Image magazine contains 16 patterns for women in sizes 34-52 (U.S. 4-22, XS-3XL) and provides access to 3 downloadable PDF patterns. B-Trendy magazine comes with 20 patterns and codes for 3 PDF downloads for girls and boys from 1 to 14 years old. There are also individual PDF patterns available for purchase on the Made by Oranges website, too.


All of the patterns contain instructions in 5 languages (Dutch, German, French, Spanish and English). The patterns included in the magazine are heavily layered and overlapped, so they require tracing (think Burdastyle), and I noticed that the PDFs also require some tracing, too. They do not include seam allowances.


I'm going to focus on My Image today because women's patterns are my jam. I received My Image issue #13, which focuses on fall patterns, although some of them could be multi-seasonal depending on your fabric choice. 


Let's talk about the size chart for My Image: the patterns run from size 34-52 (U.S. size 4-22), which is up to a 48.8" bust and 50" hip. However, I noticed upon closer inspection that not all of the patterns span the entire size range. It seems a little bit random, but some patterns are 34-52, some 36-50, some only up to a 48. So keep a close eye out to make sure the pattern you're looking at comes in your size! In issue #13, 6 out of 16 patterns go up to size 52, 5 only up to size 50 and 5 top out at size 48. Both PDF patterns go up to size 52. The third PDF pattern is a handbag. No finished measurements for the garments are provided.

There is a nice mix of simple and more complicated patterns in My Image, as well as a mix of traditional basics (examples: simple t-shirt dress) and funky modern patterns (dropped crotch track pants). There are patterns for 5 dresses, 2 skirts, 5 tops/sweaters/tunics, 3 pairs of trousers, a blazer/jacket, a coat, a coatigan, and a handbag. Have a look at the video below in which I leaf through issue #13:


The magazine does not have any stories or articles; it's truly a pattern magazine, full of photos of the patterns, the patterns themselves, and the instructions. The photos in the magazine are lovely- the coordinated fabrics are visually appealing and I love that each pattern is shown sewn up in several different fabrics. I did find, however, that the fabric choices (lots of prints) sometimes obscured the design lines (there are technical pattern drawings, though, so no worried). The instructions seem fairly minimal and mainly narrative, but do include fabric layouts as well as diagrams for the more complicated steps, such as welt pockets or sleeve plackets. 


I chose to make the Elsa Sweater, an on-trend off-the-shoulder sweater pattern that is available in the magazine and as a PDF pattern (currently free, see below!). I was attracted to this pattern because it seemed to be not too off the shoulder... sort of a nod to the trend, but more wearable in my perspective. Does that make sense? All the versions in the magazine are quite lovely. The style is a bit outside of my typical comfort zone, so somewhat of a risk, but worth a try!


Rather than trace from the magazine, I opted to print the 9-page PDF and trace from that, figuring if I had to trace, I might as well simplify it for myself a bit. I still went a bit cross-eyed tracing, probably because I'm not used to it, but highlighting the lines helped. The pattern provided measurements to draft your own rectangular cuffs and hem band.


For the Elsa Sweater, the fabric suggestions ("Suggested fabrics: Use stretchable fabric! - Knitted fabric") and fabric amounts ("Fabric usage: 205-205-210-210-210-210-210-210 cm.") left me with some questions (how stretchable should the knit be? what width fabric?), but based on the photos in the magazine, I decided I needed a thicker, less stretchy knit to achieve the proper look for the neck/shoulder pieces. I opted for some magenta ponte. Based on laying out the pattern pieces as instructed, it appears that the fabric needs to be 60" wide.


Some of the instructions for the Elsa sweater used some odd phrasing and were quite sparse, but were generally fine. I think there was a mistake for the hem band- the measurements have you draft a pattern piece for the whole band, but then the cutting layout shows it cut on the fold. I deviated a little bit from the instructions by sewing the sleeves in flat, rather than in the round.


I cut a size 46 and shortened the sleeves to 3/4 length; I held the sleeve pieces up against my Cashmerette Appleton sleeves for comparison and cut 4" off the bottom. Then, after trying the sweater on, I opted to use my twin needle to hem the sleeves and body by 3/4", without the hem band, as they were plenty long as is.


In the end, I have mixed feelings about the top... the fit is fine, maybe a little bit big. And, as Gillian said, the armscye seems quite long, which is causing a little bit of weirdness under the arm and at the bust.


My main problem, though, is that the shoulder cowl/collar piece is just not the right shape for my shoulders, obviously. The curve is just all wrong. It's too big for my shoulders (not really the top of the shoulders, but the side?) causing it to sag and look sad. No amount of ironing on the ham seems to help- there's just too much extra room there and the fabric drapes in a lumpy, unflattering way. It's almost like I need to wear askew football shoulder pads to fill it out? I don't know whose side shoulders would fill this out. I wonder if it would work better in a stiffer fabric? Then again, I worry in a stiffer fabric I would look line a linebacker, or Tina Turner in the Thunderdome! I haven't decided how/if I'll try to fix it.


 That said, I'm not going to let my mixed feelings about this sweater stop me from trying another My Image pattern- so many cute options! I really like the track pants and the sailor-style trousers, too. And there's a coat and coatigan that are pretty lovely.


If the magazine or patterns tempt you, too, lucky you! Made by Oranges provided me with a discount code to share with you: if you use the code "Meg" you can get a 25% discount on all products from Made by Oranges, including individual magazines, PDF patterns and magazine subscriptions. The code is valid through December 1.

Also, right now there are 3 free downloadable PDF patterns available if you want to give them a try: the multi-paneled Pam skirt, the off-the-shoulder Elsa sweater that I made and the Scarlet dress for kids.


Check out Sew Manju and Crafting a Rainbow for more reviews of My Image. Manju made a lovely version of the Sarah dress, one of the PDF patterns that come free with the magazine, and Gillian made a beautiful version of the magazine's faux wrap dress.

Thanks for Made by Oranges for letting me try out these magazines!

22 comments:

  1. I love that Thunderdome costume, it's on my "one day for Halloween" bucket list, but no, not the look you want everyday.:) I wonder how they jigged it to make it sit so nicely on the magazine model....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thunderdome would make a truly stunning costume! You are the queen of costumes- I bet you could make it happen!

      Delete
  2. I really feel that the ponte you chose was actually too stiff, or too tight of a knit, for a "sweater". I certainly wouldn't do anything stiffer. I think the shoulders might have draped better with some sort of looser sweater knit fabric. Although, the magazine photo seems to have more of a slant on that curve rather than the more rounded curve than the pattern seems to have. Love your posts!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe you're right... my fabric choice is definitely not right. I do think I'd still have to take some of that curve out of the shoulder no matter what fabric I chose- there is like 3-4 inches of extra room there!

      Delete
  3. The sweater is cute and I love the color but I see what you mean about the collar.... It needs some tweaking. Thanks for such a thorough review!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Margo! It definitely needs some tweaking- I may set it aside for a while and have another go at it later!

      Delete
  4. You tired a new pattern and that is good. I sometimes feel that I am attracted to a pattern and when I make it, it is all sorts of wrong on me. I do like the color on you. Maybe you could save it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Annie! Yeah, I think I can save it; I may set it aside for a while and have another go at it later!

      Delete
  5. I love your sweater. It looks great on you. I would like to try the pattern.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Mickey! Lucky for you, the PDF pattern is free!

      Delete
  6. I love your sweater. It looks great on you. I would like to try the pattern.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thank you for introducing us to a new sewing pattern magazine! I agree that the ponte fabric is too stiff for this sweater. Maybe you can take the collar off and rescue the rest to be a tee shirt? It is such a good color on you!! I would try the pattern again in a soft, luxurious knit - I can picture it with a fiber such as angora in the mix. I do like the style of the pattern and think it, too, would look great on you with a different fabric. Let us know if you "rescue" it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, Patricia, the fabric is not quite right, although I think the shoulders would still be the wrong shape for me even in a sweater knit. I'll work on it and see if I can fix it!

      Delete
  8. Meg, from the first pic, I was concerned about the shoulders. Guessing you're not wide enough in this area for the pattern to fit straight out the box. But aside from that the colour is beautiful and looks great on you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha ha, thank you for your concern, Abbey! I'll see if I can fix the shoulders because it's worth saving for the color alone!

      Delete
  9. This top definitely has potential. I am with you on the off the shoulder trend and this looks really nice. I have made a few My Image in the past and although I love their designs I have had mixed results with some of their patterns.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree it has potential - just needs some tweaking!
      My Image does have some appealing designs- interesting to know it's not just me finding them hit-or-miss...

      Delete
  10. I love that colour on you! I agree the shoulder fit is a bit strange? Who are these football players they are drafting for? LOL. I got a copy of these magazines too, and while I loved looking through them for inspiration, and I really like some of the designs, I'm not sure anything jumped out at me enough to get traced and made. We'll see! I was happy to read your review and get your thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Heather! Yeah, definitely a weird fit on the shoulders- I find it hard to imagine who would fit into it!

      Delete
  11. Thank you for your review. I was goifling to find reviews and found yours.
    One thing that striked me in your review was the mention of not knowing what width of fabric was meant to be used, and dreading having to trace.
    I thought: Well now you know how it is (tongue in cheek). I have sewn from US patterns, and quite often they assume that certain things are obvious and doesn't have to be mentioned, when when they in fact that are specific to US. Like seam allowance being included in the pattern. Or fabric being 120 cm wide.
    Oh and I absolutely despise having to print pdf patterns, tape and cut and trace. I choose to trace any day.
    Funny how what we are used to is "normal" and "easy".

    ReplyDelete